[SLED] The Polychronic Classroom (Don't Be Naive, Native,or Immigrant)

Hollins, Paul P.A.Hollins at bolton.ac.uk
Tue Apr 3 02:54:48 PDT 2007


Hi Daniel,
 
I don't know about being the *most* you might recall my comments at the recent HEA event (which incidentally I thought was an excellent event) taking one of the presenters to task over his (mis)use of the metaphors.
 
I agree that it can lead to misattribution of proficiency, if people insist on using the metaphor, I can accept the terms as two points on a continuum but not related directly to age more to proficiency.
 
Paul Hollins

________________________________

From: educators-bounces at lists.secondlife.com on behalf of Daniel Livingstone
Sent: Tue 03/04/2007 10:04
To: SL Educators
Subject: Re: [SLED] The Polychronic Classroom (Don't Be Naive, Native,or Immigrant)


I'm quite possibly the single person on this mailing list
who *most* dislikes the native/immigrant terminology.

I think its innaccurate, misleading, leads to incorrect and quite
possibly harmful mis-attribution of technical proficiency to 
students who may understand (in many cases) less about
technology (and how to use it) than we assume. 

I have a habit of going on and on about this... starting here:
http://learninggames.wordpress.com/tag/digital-natives/page/3/

Lots of posts, lots of links and discussion to other articles - some
making similar points to my own.

daniel



On 02/04/07, Bill Freese <iedbf at montana.edu> wrote: 

	Howdy,
	Robert Benchly said, "There are two kinds of people in the world,
	those who believe there are two kinds of people in the world and
	those who don't." We draw that line (immigrant / native or
	polychronic / monochronic or whatever / antiwhatever) because it
	helps us to understand something. But the line is always artificial,
	and the people are always multifaceted beings who exist in various
	positions on various behavioral spectra. I found the Prensky article 
	to be enlightening, particularly the idea of digital immigrants
	speaking with an accent. 


-- 

http://learninggames.wordpress.com 


More information about the Educators mailing list